Ireland vs. Argentina Preview

Sean O’Brien makes a timely return

After an emphatic victory over Italy last weekend in Chicago, Ireland lock horns against Argentina at the Aviva Stadium. The team selection made by Joe Schmidt is strong and shows the respect that the Ireland team have for the Argentinians. Hawkeye Sidekick runs the rule over the selections. 

Sean O’Brien returns for Ireland

Given the strong squad depth chart for Ireland, the omissions of Rob Kearney, Garry Ringrose and Tadhg Beirne are noted but not devastating to the Ireland setup.

The key talking point is the return of Sean O’Brien to the back row unit where he slots in alongside Peter O’Mahony and CJ Stander. Injuries issues aplenty for the Tullow native but it is clear that Joe Schmidt has selected O’Brien to provide abrasiveness in his ball carrying, tackling and all round play. O’Brien needs to impress given the huge depth chart in the back row position. Josh van der Flier, Dan Leavy, Rhys Ruddock, Jordi Murphy all chomping at the bit to get game time. Tadhg Beirne is a viable option in the unit too.

This is a strong lineup to kickoff the home Autumn International series. The front five looks compact and Iain Henderson will be keen to impress alongside James Ryan in the second row given that Devin Toner is on the bench and Tadhg Beirne is out of the matchday squad. The front row looks incredibly strong with Healy, Best and Furlong looking to unsettle an Argentine front row which has struggled in set piece this season.

The half back partnership will be keenly watched. How will Marmion manage the game? Can Marmion provide quick ruck ball for Sexton to launch his runners?

The three quarters and back three are loaded with talent and physicality. Aki and Henshaw will carry with abrasive purpose while Larmour, Earls and Stockdale will look to impress in the back three. Larmour’s attacking lines are superb but want to see him tested defensively and under the high ball against Argentina to get a full read on the player. 

Argentina shift personnel and captaincy

Mario Ledesma has shifted the team with six changes and a change in captaincy. Creevy starts at hooker but loses the captaincy to Matera. The key theme from the selection is the added bulk to the back row as Petti (a lock) slots into the back row; an indication that Argentina want to meet Ireland head on in the set piece (line out) and pack exchanges.

Sanchez at ten is a superb footballer and will look to Cubelli to provide quick ruck ball to allow  him to launch an exciting back line containing Delguy and Boffelli. A solid outfit which should experience as severe cohesion issues as typically seen by national teams this time of year as all the squad are from the Jaguares. 

Game Plan

It is an interesting question to pose. Argentina have evolved their game plan in recent year. Their dependency on total pack supremacy on the back of a slick aerial game has significantly reduced as the Jaguares and now the national team have refocused to play a more expansive style of game. They will look to spread the ball out wide to test Ireland’s outside defense early doors. 

What do Ireland do? To engage in a highly unstructured game would favor Argentina but the smart play will be to focus initially on pack platform, look to expose the visitors in the scrum. The line out looks interesting with the inclusion of Petti in the Argentinian side; a third viable line out jumper for the South Americans.

Sexton will be eager to launch his runners but I think the theme will be patience; play the phases in the tight and when the opportunities arise, launch Henshaw and Aki to secure gain line advantages that will utilize the Ireland back three. 

Verdict

A good solid test match for Ireland ahead of their New Zealand challenge on November 20th. Ireland will be tested by Argentina in their fast attacking game but the pack platform advantage lies with Ireland here. This is the focal point for victory and despite Argentina’s resiliency, think this is a test match where Ireland will look to issue a statement of intent to all others. Ireland by ten points. 

Argentina: Ireland’s Nemesis

Argentina poses threats to Ireland

After the Chicago Soldier Field test match, Ireland must reset and focus on their next assignment, an assignment against an opposition who have broken their hearts in previous RWC tournaments.

Argentina form guide

Argentina come to the Aviva Stadium on the back of a strong Rugby Championship where the South Americans beat South Africa (H) and Australia (A) and were competitive against New Zealand in both fixtures.

The sore point for Argentina in the Rugby Championship was their second half collapse at home to Australia surrendering a huge lead to lose 34-45, the collapse was the second biggest comeback win in the history of test match rugby. It has prompted a change in captaincy as veteran Creevy is relieved of the captaincy in favor of the youthful, exuberance of back row forward Pablo Mantera. 

What is the squad makeup? 

The Argentinian squad is one which should be cohesive in the pack and back line. This is because the vast majority of the side ply their club careers with the Argentine franchise Jaguares who are in the Super Rugby competition. They have progressed well in the competition, progressively rising up the rankings with a respectable seventh position this season after finishing tenth in 2017 and thirteenth in the standings for the 2016 season. A squad which is evolving with the Jaguares should see improvement as well for the national team come RWC 2019.  

Head Coach

A name that Ireland will know very. Mario Ledesma was an accomplished hooker who had a successful playing career in France and National side. A natural leader, Ledesma led Argentina superbly in the 2007 to a semi-final appearance and continued in that same vain in 2011 RWC where Argentina succumbed to New Zealand in the quarter finals. Coaching stints in Australia and France developed his managerial skill set to take over Jaguares and Argentina national teams in 2018. A man who will make the tough decisions evident in his demotion of Creevy as captain before this tour. 

Game Plan

The Argentinian style of play has evolved quite significantly in recent years. The routine box kicking and pack platform supremacy game plan of the past has fundamentally shifted. The side likes to express themselves with ball in hand, look to be expansive when the opportunities arise with a steadily improving offloading game. 

Players to Watch

The back three threat at the weekend have pace, power and footballing skill to keep Ireland on their toes. Delguy and Boffelli had excellent seasons with their club Jaguares and their pace and ability to create line breaks were seen in the Rugby Championship this season. Moyano is a player who given time and space will destroy opposition. 

The half-back partnership is very experienced. Sanchez is a quality fly-half operator who will ping to the corners when required but his ability to bring his back line unit into the game is a key strength. Landajo is a solid scrum half, no frills and will look to distribute fast ruck ball. Ireland’s back row unit will need to slow down ball to contain the half-back threat of Argentina. 

The back row unit led by Pablo Mantera will look to cut loose in their ball carrying. Mantera is a back row who loves to carry endless ball and will look to offload at every opportunity and will be ably assisted by experienced operator Leguizamón. 

Potential Weak Point

The second row unit contains the brilliance of Lavanini in the ranks. His line out and set piece execution is genuinely world class. However, questions have persisted on the front five cohesion during the summer and Rugby Championship test match series. 

The front row, traditionally an area of strength has become an area where squad depth has being exposed. Ledesma will hope that the front row unit containing Creevy and Herrera can provide the stability required but after that, squad depth quality in the prop positions dips and this is an area of concern for Argentina ahead of the Autumn and RWC 2019 fixtures.